– The Backcountry Ski Touring Blog
  • Avalanches
  • Gear Reviews
    • Ski Reviews
    • Boot Reviews
    • Binding Reviews
    • Snowboard Splitboard
    • Book Reviews
    • Avalanche Beacon Reviews
    • Airbag Backpacks
    • Backcountry Electronics
    • Misc Gear Reviews
  • Podcast
  • Tips & Tricks
    • Ski Touring Basics
    • Boot Fitting
    • Fitness & Health
    • Gear Mods
  • Trip Reports
    • Fourteeners
    • Huts – Cabins – Lodges
    • Denali McKinley
    • 8,000 Meter Skiing
  • Stories
    • History
    • Humor
    • Land Use Issues
    • Evergreen Ski Touring
    • Poetry
  • Resources
    • All Posts Listed
    • 100 Recent Comments
    • Backcountry Skiing & Ski Touring Webcams
    • Ski Weights Comparison
    • Archives of WildSnow.com
    • Authors Page
    • Ski Touring Bindings
      • Trab TR2 Index and FAQ
      • Salomon Guardian & Tracker
      • Naxo Backcountry Skiing Bindings – Info Index
      • Silvretta Pure Backcountry Skiing Bindings – Info Index
      • Marker F10-12 Duke Baron
      • G3 Onyx Ski Binding FAQ
      • G3 ION Ski Touring Binding
      • Fritschi Backcountry Skiing Bindings – Info Index
      • Fritschi Diamir Frame Bindings Mount DIY
      • Fritschi Diamir Bindings FAQ
      • Fritschi Tecton FAQ
      • Atomic Salomon Backland MTN
      • Dynafit Tri-Step Binding 2001-2003
      • Naxo randonnee alpine touring AT ski binding FAQ
      • Dynafit Skiing Bindings – Info Index
      • Dynafit Binding Frequently Asked Questions FAQ
      • Dynafit Beast 16 FAQ Review 1
      • Dynafit Beast 16 FAQ Page Two
    • History
      • Ski Touring Binding Museum
      • Trooper Traverse Intro & Index
      • Randonnee Ski Touring “AT” ski gear — What is Hip?
      • Chronology
    • Backcountry Skiing Core Glossary
    • Gear Review Policy & Disclosures

– The Backcountry Ski Touring Blog

Banner
  • Avalanches
  • Gear Reviews
    • Ski Reviews
    • Boot Reviews
    • Binding Reviews
    • Snowboard Splitboard
    • Book Reviews
    • Avalanche Beacon Reviews
    • Airbag Backpacks
    • Backcountry Electronics
    • Misc Gear Reviews
  • Podcast
  • Tips & Tricks
    • Ski Touring Basics
    • Boot Fitting
    • Fitness & Health
    • Gear Mods
  • Trip Reports
    • Fourteeners
    • Huts – Cabins – Lodges
    • Denali McKinley
    • 8,000 Meter Skiing
  • Stories
    • History
    • Humor
    • Land Use Issues
    • Evergreen Ski Touring
    • Poetry
  • Resources
    • All Posts Listed
    • 100 Recent Comments
    • Backcountry Skiing & Ski Touring Webcams
    • Ski Weights Comparison
    • Archives of WildSnow.com
    • Authors Page
    • Ski Touring Bindings
      • Trab TR2 Index and FAQ
      • Salomon Guardian & Tracker
      • Naxo Backcountry Skiing Bindings – Info Index
      • Silvretta Pure Backcountry Skiing Bindings – Info Index
      • Marker F10-12 Duke Baron
      • G3 Onyx Ski Binding FAQ
      • G3 ION Ski Touring Binding
      • Fritschi Backcountry Skiing Bindings – Info Index
      • Fritschi Diamir Frame Bindings Mount DIY
      • Fritschi Diamir Bindings FAQ
      • Fritschi Tecton FAQ
      • Atomic Salomon Backland MTN
      • Dynafit Tri-Step Binding 2001-2003
      • Naxo randonnee alpine touring AT ski binding FAQ
      • Dynafit Skiing Bindings – Info Index
      • Dynafit Binding Frequently Asked Questions FAQ
      • Dynafit Beast 16 FAQ Review 1
      • Dynafit Beast 16 FAQ Page Two
    • History
      • Ski Touring Binding Museum
      • Trooper Traverse Intro & Index
      • Randonnee Ski Touring “AT” ski gear — What is Hip?
      • Chronology
    • Backcountry Skiing Core Glossary
    • Gear Review Policy & Disclosures
   

BD/PIEPS Safety Checks—72 hours In

by Jason Albert April 18, 2022
written by Jason Albert April 18, 2022

Early Friday, Black Diamond announced that some BD/Pieps Avalanche Beacons owners should perform safety checks to ensure their products operate correctly. According to Black Diamond’s statement, in question are beacons with “malfunctioning electronic components that may prevent it from switching between SEND and SEARCH modes.” The company asked owners to perform a safety test to determine if their beacon functioned properly. BD did not officially recall any beacons at the time of the statement.

I own a Barryvox S beacon and often keep a few older Ortovox 3+ beacons in my ski duffle if anyone forgets their beacon. I am only familiar with the BD/Pieps beacon line through my readings on WildSnow, or fiddling with my primary partner’s beacon; he uses a Pieps Pro BT. This model was on the list for a mandatory safety inspection. (BD cited nine beacon models, all listed below, in the press release.)

Left to Right: PIEPS Micro BT Button, PIEPS Micro BT Race, PIEPS Micro BT Sensor, PIEPS Powder BT, PIEPS Pro BT

Left to Right: PIEPS DSP Pro, PIEPS DSP Sport, Black Diamond Recon BT, Black Diamond Guide BT

After snagging his beacon, I familiarized myself with the safety check. It was basic, which raises more questions. But first, here’s more on BD’s safety check, which I completed without using the PIEPS phone app.

The Safety Check Directions for the Pieps Pro BT:

“Move the slider lock to the left and the mode slider upwards in the position SEARCH.
1. Make sure the SEARCH symbol (- -) appears on the display
2. Move the slider downwards, until it locks in position SEND
3. Make sure the SEND symbol (X) appears on the display
4. Move the slider lock to the left and the mode slider downwards in the position OFF.
5. Make sure that beacon is turned off.
6. If switching between the modes is not possible, please enter your details below and we will contact you.”

This safety check was simple enough; the mode slider moved to search, send, and off seamlessly. All the appropriate symbols appeared. Test passed for now.

The first and lowest of the hanging-fruit questions that pop up is how do we know the electronics will operate appropriately for the lifetime of the beacon, meaning every day the beacon is in the field? Again, my primary partner uses one of these beacons. I suppose I have skin in the game.

When asked BD’s emailed response was, “A device check is sufficient to confirm whether the unit is affected in the manufacturing process deviation. This does not preclude the need to follow best practice and check your safety device prior to use.”

I’m also curious to know what the hard evidence was that some electronic systems are/were defective and, at the time of the press release, what did the company suspect might be the cause?

“We examined warranted/returned units and identified the electronic component failure, triggering the investigation. The root cause has been narrowed to material handling / assembly anomaly in manufacturing,” stated BD in the same email.

***

I don’t run a multi-million dollar company. Still, I know in terms of the outdoor community and peoples’ safety, it’s best to get in front of any controversy with 100% transparency. Most companies, and some people, rely on sassy branding. But the underpinnings of any good branding are reliable products. What makes companies like BD viable is consumer trust.

I’ll back up a bit. I’ve owned plenty of solid and cherished pieces from Chouinard Equipment (and from BD for that matter). Chouinard Equipment made a hard pivot after several lawsuits involving harnesses and eventually became the Salt Lake-based employee-owned Black Diamond Equipment many of us relied on for climbing and skiing goods. (For some great backstory on the first CEO of BD, Peter Metcalf, listen to this Enormocast episode. It’s solid.)

I switched from rigid stem Friends to original BD Camelots in, I think, 94′. Two or three of those well-cared for cams are still in the rotation when tripling up on sizes. But we’ve mostly upgraded. On his first trip to Yosemite during a crash course in cracks, my son took a sizable whip on one of those old Camelots. It held. Which is to say, I trust their stuff. I love that kid.

BD eventually sold to the Clarus Corporation in 2010 for a reported $90million. Clarus is currently a SLC-based publicly traded company, and it also owns PIEPS, which is based in Austria.

For those of you keen on following the backcountry scene, this is all déjà vu. Black Diamond and PIEPS have been here before. And recently.

10/20/20: WildSnow reports on social media posts regarding potentially flawed lock mechanisms on Pieps DSP Pro and DSP Sport beacons.

3/4/21: WildSnow reports on BD/PIEPS voluntary recall in Europe.

4/12/21: BD releases a statement titled “Black Diamond Recalls Pieps DSP Avalanche Transceivers Due to Risk of Loss of Emergency Communications.”

4/13/21: WildSnow reports on the details of the North American recall.

Noting the timeline above, it took many months for BD/PIEPS to lick some of their self-inflicted wounds. So if this is déjà vu for the backcountry community, it’s undoubtedly déjà vu for BD/PIEPS. The fury on social media over the first 24 hours of the press release cuts. The memes burn too. This is safety gear, after all. We’re now 72 hours into this, and the demand for recalls, refunds, and BD/PIEPS’ move away from beacon manufacturing altogether is playing out.

Noah Howell, a former BD pro athlete, posted this Instagram regarding his experience with past BD efforts to mitigate beacon problems.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by @noah_j_howell

I can imagine way back in time, maybe at the dawn of semi-intelligence, someone uttered their version of this: “fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me.”

Jason Albert

Jason Albert comes to WildSnow from Bend, Oregon. After growing up on the East Coast, he migrated from Montana to Colorado and settled in Oregon. Simple pleasures are quiet and long days touring. His gray hair might stem from his first Grand Traverse in 2000 when rented leather boots and 210cm skis were not the speed weapons he had hoped for. Jason survived the transition from free-heel kool-aid drinker to faster and lighter (think AT), and safer, are better.

10 comments
0
FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
previous post
PSA: PIEPS and Black Diamond Equipment Avalanche Transceiver / Beacon Safety Check
next post
Tecnica Zero G Peak Carbon: First Look

10 comments

Jack April 18, 2022 - 11:34 am

I don’t own one of these beacons, but my curiosity is aroused by the non-specificity of their description of the problem. So, what are the properties of the failure, specifically? Most semiconductor part failures occur on a “bathtub” or U-shaped curve. Failures are high during an initial period, the left edge of the U, stay at a more-or-less flat and low rate, the bottom of the U, for a long period of time, and then rise as end-of-life effects take place. Is the problem with damaged semiconductor devices (electrostatic shock prior to assembly being a common cause)? Or, do some devices exhibit an unusually high failure even past early-life failures? The answers to these questions make a difference. If the beacon “safety checks” now, that says nothing about its probability of failing next week or next month unless we know the time characteristics of the observed failures. The same reasoning applies to many electro-mechanical failures. Give us the specific failure information and prove to us that the proscribed safety check actually rules a beacon as outside the group likely to fail. TL;DR safety check smells like a feel-good check. Give the owners the data!

Tuck April 18, 2022 - 11:35 am

This frankly sounds like Monday morning quarterbacking. What do you suggest they do differently? Make flawless products? That’s not possible, especially with electronics…

CB April 18, 2022 - 5:57 pm

Tuck, other companies have had small problems with their beacons. But NONE have had the sort of deny and spin like BD has with the last TWO problems that have claimed people’s lives. Even AFTER people had died they denied and delayed.

CD April 18, 2022 - 7:16 pm

@Tuck, you commented similarly on the first post on this topic the other day. Do you work for BD?

People are reacting to the fact that they’ve had two poorly communicated recalls in barely more than a year. Recalls of critical life safety products, at that. That’s a huge black eye to a company in this space, and it’s totally reasonable that people are going to react strongly to the news.

It’s odd to me that you see this happening and feel like BD needs you to defend them.

Jack April 18, 2022 - 11:57 am

All I am suggesting is that if they are observing high failure rates and admitting it, then spot-checking the beacon you own now just says it hasn’t failed yet and could still be in the “likely to fail at a much higher than normal rate” category. In other words, a feel good measure.

Joel April 18, 2022 - 2:19 pm

I have the BD Guide beacon, so this directly impacts me and those I ski with. BD’s response is extremely lacking in comfort. My beacon works fine when tested and used in practice drills. SO, what I need to know from BD before I trust my beacon again is whether there is a chance that at some point my beacon will stop working due to this flaw. Likely my last BD/Pieps beacon.

Al April 18, 2022 - 8:19 pm

isnt Pieps a brand from yurp and BD is their sales representative in N.A. ?

Jason April 19, 2022 - 10:35 am

Clarus owns both BD and Pieps, you can find Clarus’ brands listed out here:https://www.claruscorp.com/our-brands. Pieps, as far as I know, designs and manufactures the BD branded beacons. But, either way, it’s all under the same umbrella.

Mark April 20, 2022 - 6:36 am

I have a replacement beacon (Powder BT) after returning a DSP Sport in the first part of this mess. At the time I thought Pieps did the right thing, although they were dragged there kicking and screaming.

What I want to know now is whether this fault, if it is present, is present out of the box. If not, and it develops over time, then when, and under what circumstances? Do I need to be doing this check every time I use the beacon? So many unanswered questions and so much resistance to providing them. This company is going to need a change in leadership for this culture to be turned around.

Greg April 20, 2022 - 11:11 am

Their recommended safety check procedure is the same as the trailhead beacon check I do before every tour. Confirm search mode, confirm transmit mode, go skiing. BD/Pieps is essentially saying “If your beacon is broken, then it’s broken. Otherwise it’s not broken.” No range of impacted serial numbers or manufacture dates. A wide variety of models over several generations and many production years. No indication if the failure rate increases over time. They may not have answers yet, but they should be transparent about what they do and do not know. Not confidence inspiring.

My wife had a Pieps DSP Pro, which she was happy with until the switch feature defect came to light. After confirming that the switch on her unit could move without pressing the lock button, we paid $100 to upgrade to a new Pieps Pro BT with the improved switch lock mechanism. Seemed like a better idea vs the band-aid hard case. Now we just want our money back so we can buy a transceiver from BCA, Ortovox, or Mammut.

Comments are closed.

Recent Comments

  • Jim Milstein on The Sanctity of Space—A Film Review
  • Natalie Stavn on Norrøna Lyngen Gore-Tex Pro Pants Review
  • Hacksaw on The Sanctity of Space—A Film Review
  • Doug on More Ski Days on the TLT X
  • Jason on More Ski Days on the TLT X

Gear Reviews

  • Phantom Slipper and Slipper HD – TESTED

    May 26, 2022
  • Revisiting the Blue Ice Harfang Crampon

    May 24, 2022
  • Patagonia Micro Puff Storm Jacket

    May 19, 2022

Trip Reports

  • Mount Sanford from the Road

    May 9, 2022
  • Techniques and considerations for ski mountaineering on glaciers

    February 16, 2022
  • Making the Most out of the Alaska Range

    February 14, 2022

Totally Deep Podcast

  • Totally Deep Podcast 99: Big Geography with Roman Dial and Alex Lee

    April 20, 2022
  • TOTALLY DEEP PODCAST 98: Live at the EMGT with Cam Smith

    April 12, 2022
  • TOTALLY DEEP PODCAST 97: Talk of Gear for Next Year

    March 23, 2022

Tips & Tricks

  • A Shoulder Season Ski Traverse: Three People, Three Sleep Systems

    May 27, 2022
  • Springtime Primer: Securing Skis/Splitboard to a Bike Frame

    May 16, 2022
  • Fueling For Ski Touring

    May 3, 2022

Ski Touring Stories

  • Stumbling through Sagebrush and into the Danger Zone on Steens Mountain

    May 31, 2022
  • Update: Bighorn Sheep and Backcountry Skiers/Riders in the Tetons

    April 26, 2022
  • Backscratchers in My Brain

    April 6, 2022

Newsletter Sign-Up

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • About Lou Dawson
  • Authors Page
  • About
  • Contact
  • Copyright & Legal
  • Website Security

@2020 - All Rights Reserved. Designed and Developed by WildSnow


Back To Top

Read alsox

The Sanctity of Space—A Film Review

June 29, 2022

More Ski Days on the TLT...

June 27, 2022

Low Tech Safety with the Snow...

June 24, 2022