Update: I added info about warm weather liner, and a few other edits. See bottom of post for the liner, it’s nice, minimalist!
As many of you know, I’m not particularly impressed with the protection ski helmets offer. The sometimes vaunted manufacturing standards are really quite minimal — they could be stricter, with more attention to the danger of concussion from repeated lower energy impacts (not to mention more protection in general).
Distrust of actual protection notwithstanding, I found myself last winter wishing I was wearing a skull shell during our night tours. If for no other reason than as a headlamp mount, but also considering we did have a few skitters on glazed snow. Speaking of which, I had an embarrassing little incident while skinning on an ice glazed 30 degree moderate ski run — a sliding fall could have put me into a tree. I wasn’t moving downhill fast, but could not stop. Terrifying. Consumer type (Category B, see below) ski helmets are not known to significantly protect you from high speed impacts, but a glancing blow to an aspen tree during a low speed slide is exactly what they could help with. So folks, I’ll be experimenting with wearing one more frequently than before, on the up as well as down.
(Note: This is a first look, long term testing has commenced.)
Asking around among my hardcore mountaineering friends, I got good reports on the Salomon MTN Lab helm. Designed specifically for ski touring, this helmet is reasonably ventilated, light at 372 grams. My tester is white. With helmets, heat is often the enemy. That especially true for cardio uphilling and spring ski touring. No sense stoking the furnace with dark color sun absorption. On the other hand, a darker colored helmet might be on the agenda for winter, as a white helmet in avalanche terrain could be a strike against a quick rescue.
Configured for summer without ear flaps, I’ll even try the Salomon for road bike riding (it would clearly be too hot for grinding out mountain bike hill climbs, despite its MTN moniker).
You can configure the MTN helmet to somewhat hold a headlamp using the rear goggle retainer and two headlamp dedicated clips on the sides. Nonetheless, as with many other helmets I found the MTN’s headlamp retainer configuration to be inadequate. Duct tape will clearly come into play with any sort of serious headlamp use. I’m also considering mounting the Petzl headlamp optional mounting brackets on the helmet, to eliminate the pesky straps. More on that as things progress, as a helmet is useless to me without an excellent lamp attached. https://www.backcountry.com/petzl-duo-mount
I’d prefer the front brim of the shell was about 4 millimeters higher. Depending on goggle brand and model, during dry runs at home I sometimes didn’t have enough room for the top of my goggles.
For my head shape, the fit is a bit wide left to right while snug front and back. Most of this gets adjusted by the soft headband-liner, but a more sophisticated shaping system could be good. In any case, the typical knob-crank circumference adjustment does most of what I need, changing from bare head fit to slightly larger for balaclava. I chose a shell size that’s snug, a ski cap or ball cap won’t fit inside. That’s by intent. I find helmets to usually be warm enough in of themselves, and if necessary I’ll cover with a compatible hood.
This is a hard shell helmet. It is thus a few grams heavier than a full-foam helmet with eggshell skin, but much more durable for events such as being packed in a ski bag, flying to Europe snuggled with a ski binding. It bears repeating that a hard shell offers no more impact protection than a soft shell (possibly even less), it is simply there to guard against intrusion (punji branches and sharp rocks), as well as being a solid means for attaching headlamp mounts, goggle attachments, chin straps and so on.
The combined headband and earflaps peice is easily removable (word is a summer version will be available without flaps). A combination of Merino Wool and super breathable fabrics help manage the deluge.
Average, meaning enough to do something but not enough to let in tons of snow. The vents have no closure system, for wet or extreme cold weather you’d want to tape them shut. This could be done with white duct tape applied to the outside.
This is not a MIPS (rotation damping) helmet. That’s by intent as we’re clearly after something minimal (MIPS adds volume and weight). Likewise, this is not an “EN 1077 Class A” snowsports helmet, but rather a “Class B,” meaning it indeed offers less protection, but is equal in protection to most of the ski helmets you see folks using. Why not a Class A for ski touring? The shell of a class A covers the ears (think an alpine racing helmet), it’s heavier, and has smaller or no vent holes. Compromise. At least Salomon is up front about what standards the MTN Lab conforms to, stated on a clearly worded sticker inside the shell. Mountaineers, note the MTN also conforms to the EN 12492 standard for climbing helmets. That’s excellent in terms of multi-purpose.
A lightweight nicely designed helmet. A few more fitting pad options would be appreciated, e.g., the summer liner without ear flaps. Headlamp and goggle retention are not ignored, but I’d have expected Salomon to do better. Overall, recommended.
ADDENDUM — THE SUMMER LINER
Apparently they’re not importing the “summer” MTN helmet liner to North America, but they’re available in Europe. I acquired and checked out. Nice. Pretty much what I’d use for any ski tour, as helmet ear flaps are usually overkill. Photos follow.